Skip to content
Preview mode: Supabase isn't connected, so voting, comments and forms are off. See README.
Satire & opinion · CanadaSign in

Vol. 01 · The Inaugural List

Canada’s 10 Worst Food Critics

“For once, the critics are on the menu.”

They’ve spent years judging restaurants. Now it’s their turn. Welcome to Rotten Critics, where Canada’s food critics get a taste of their own medicine.

I.

The editorial order

We wrote the first list. It is subjective, provisional and entirely ours. Consider it the amuse-bouche, not the verdict.

II.

The community verdict

Then the dining room takes over. A critic needs 50 votes before they can be seated in the community ranking.

III.

The receipts

Jokes are opinion. Facts get sources. Anything we can't link to a published original doesn't run.

The inaugural editorial order

The Ten

Provisional · Editorial

Our opinion, in our order. Not a statistical ranking and not a finding about anyone’s competence. The community order takes over once 10 critics have 50+ votes each (0 of 10 so far). How scoring works.

  1. 1

    The Self-Appointed Supreme Court of Dinner

    Lesley Chesterman

    The roast is still resting. Copy to come.

    Read the file →
    CommunityUnscored

    Voting opens when the database is connected.

  2. 2

    The Last Word

    Alexandra Gill

    The roast is still resting. Copy to come.

    Read the file →
    CommunityUnscored

    Voting opens when the database is connected.

  3. 5

    The Sommelier at the Pass

    Mark DeWolf

    The Coast · Halifax

    Perhaps the next time a chef visits a vineyard, they should publish a review of the winemaking.

    Read the file →
    CommunityUnscored

    Voting opens when the database is connected.

  4. 6

    The Professional Enthusiast

    Renée Suen

    The roast is still resting. Copy to come.

    Read the file →
    CommunityUnscored

    Voting opens when the database is connected.

  5. 7

    The Relentless Optimist

    Michelle Sproule

    Scout Magazine · The Infatuation · Vancouver

    Somewhere in Vancouver, a chef is still waiting to discover what it takes to disappoint Michelle Sproule.

    Read the file →
    CommunityUnscored

    Voting opens when the database is connected.

  6. 8

    The Food Desk Philosopher

    Karon Liu

    The roast is still resting. Copy to come.

    Read the file →
    CommunityUnscored

    Voting opens when the database is connected.

  7. 9

    The Unofficial Publicist

    Elizabeth Chorney-Booth

    Calgary Herald · Calgary

    Sometimes the most useful thing a critic can bring to dinner isn't enthusiasm. It's a little disappointment.

    Read the file →
    CommunityUnscored

    Voting opens when the database is connected.

  8. 10

    The Jazz Critic Who Stayed for Dinner

    Peter Hum

    The roast is still resting. Copy to come.

    Read the file →
    CommunityUnscored

    Voting opens when the database is connected.

The list holds ten. The directory holds everyone we’ve approved.

All critics

Nominations

Someone missing from the pass?

Nominate a Canadian restaurant critic with a public body of work. Send us a published review, not a grudge. Every nomination is checked before anyone gets a table.

Nominate a critic

Right of reply

Are you on this list?

Critics get the last word on their own page. Send a response, and once we’ve confirmed it’s you, it runs in full, unedited for substance, set apart from the comments.

Submit a response